Stottlemyer's Smokehouse in Sarasota, FL offers a diverse menu with options for everyone. From BBQ Nachos and Buffalo Chicken Dip to Cornbread Smokestacks and Fried Chicken Gizzards, the appetizers are sure to tantalize your taste buds. The sandwich selection includes classics like Brisket Sandwich, Burger, and Chicken Sandwich, all served with delicious sides. For a lighter option, try the Caesar Salad or Smokehouse Salad with your choice of protein. Customers rave about the excellent food, attentive service, and lively atmosphere at Stottlemyer's. Standout dishes include the tender Smoked Stuffed Bacon-Wrapped Jalapenos and the flavorful pulled BBQ pork with sides like cornbread and fried okra. With live music on weekends and a welcoming tiki hut dining area, Stottlemyer's Smokehouse is the perfect spot for a tasty meal and a good time.
Appetizers
Fried Green Tomatoes
$8.99Fried Pickles
$8.99Fried Mushrooms
$8.99Mozzarella Sticks with Marinara
$7.99Fried Chicken Gizzards
$8.99Fried Chicken Livers
$8.99Cornbread Smokestacks
$10.99BBQ Nachos
$14.99Vegetarian
$9.99Buffalo Chicken Dip
$8.99Smokehouse Wings - 6 Wings
$10.99Smokehouse Wings - 12 Wings
$18.99Buffalo Chicken Tenders
$9.99 Salads.
Smokehouse Salad
$16.99Steve's Garden Salad
$8.99Caesar Salad
$8.99Side Salad
$3.99 Sandwiches
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$11.99Sliced Pork Sandwich
$11.99Smokehouse Cuban Sandwich
$11.99Burger
$10.99Mushroom Swiss Burger
$13.99Brisket Sandwich
$12.99Chicken Sandwich
$10.99Mahi Sandwich
$11.99Steak Bomb Sandwich
$10.99Chicken Bomb Sandwich
$10.99Smoked Sausage Sandwich
$10.99Cuban Sandwich
$10.99 Pizza
Smokehouse Meat Lovers Pizza - 10 Inch (Gluten-Free)
$13.99Smokehouse Meat Lovers Pizza - 12 Inch
$15.99Smokehouse Meat Lovers Pizza - 16 Inch
$20.99Smokehouse Supreme Pizza - 10 Inch (Gluten-Free)
$13.99Smokehouse Supreme Pizza - 12 Inch
$15.99Smokehouse Supreme Pizza - 16 Inch
$20.99Traditional Meat Lovers Pizza - 10 Inch (Gluten-Free)
$13.99Traditional Meat Lovers Pizza - 12 Inch
$15.99Traditional Meat Lovers Pizza - 16 Inch
$20.99Traditional Supreme Pizza - 10 Inch (Gluten-Free)
$13.99Traditional Supreme Pizza - 12 Inch
$15.99Traditional Supreme Pizza - 16 Inch
$20.99Build Your Own Pizza - 12 Inch
$10.99Build Your Own Pizza - 16 Inch
$14.99 Authentic BBQ
Beef Brisket - 6 oz.
$14.99Beef Brisket - 8 oz.
$17.99Beef Brisket - 12 oz.
$23.99Smokehouse Spare Ribs - 2 Bones
$14.99Smokehouse Spare Ribs - 3 Bones
$18.99Smokehouse Spare Ribs - 5 Bones
$26.99Baby Back Ribs - Half Rack
$17.99Baby Back Ribs - Full Rack
$27.99'Smoking' BBQ Pulled Pork
$13.99Smoked Half Chicken
$15.99Famous Fried Chicken - 2 Piece White (Breast & Wing)
$12.99Famous Fried Chicken - 2 Piece Dark (Thigh & Leg)
$10.99Famous Fried Chicken - 3 Piece White (2 Breasts & Wing)
$15.99Famous Fried Chicken - 3 Piece Dark (2 Thighs & LEg)
$14.99Famous Fried Chicken Gizzard Dinner
$10.99Famous Fried Chicken Liver Dinner
$10.99Famous Fried Chicken Chicken Tenders
$12.99BBQ SAMPLER
$26.99BBQ Pork Combo
$24.99Mahi Basket
$13.99Salmon Basket
$13.99 For the Kids
Chicken Tenders
$7.99Mac & Cheese
$7.99Pulled Pork Slider
$7.99Cheese Pizza
$7.99Pepperoni Pizza
$7.99 Sides
Black Beans & Rice - 12 oz.
$9.99Black Beans & Rice - 16 oz.
$12.99Fried Okra - 12 oz.
$9.99Fried Okra - 16 oz.
$12.99Onion Rings - 12 oz.
$9.99Onion Rings - 16 oz.
$12.99French Fries - 12 oz.
$9.99French Fries - 16 oz.
$12.99Sweet Potato Fries - 12 oz.
$9.99Sweet Potato Fries - 16 oz.
$12.99Mac-N-Cheese - 12 oz.
$9.99Mac-N-Cheese - 16 oz.
$12.99Creamy Coleslaw - 12 oz.
$9.99Creamy Coleslaw - 16 oz.
$12.99Mashed Potatoes & Gravy - 12 oz.
$9.99Mashed Potatoes & Gravy - 16 oz.
$12.99BBQ Baked Beans - 12 oz.
$9.99BBQ Baked Beans - 16 oz.
$12.99Potato Salad - 12 oz.
$9.99Potato Salad - 16 oz.
$12.99Fried Cabbage - 12 oz.
$9.99Fried Cabbage - 16 oz.
$12.99Green Beans - 12 oz.
$9.99Green Beans - 16 oz.
$12.99Sweet Collard Greens - 12 oz.
$9.99Sweet Collard Greens - 16 oz.
$12.99 Desserts
Ice Cream Sundae
$4.99Brownie Sundae
$5.99Pie
$5.99Soft Serve Ice Cream Cone
$1.99 Tacos
BBQ Tacos
$10.99